We all know how wrong polls and pundits can be. They underestimated the popularity of the current president’s first successful run for office in 2016. Pundits were dead wrong about a “Red Wave” of GOP voters that never materialized in the 2022 midterms. In the last presidential election, several polls of swing states were off base.
That recent history is partly why I remained so cautiously hesitant about the possibility of Zohran Mamdani -- a Muslim of South Asian heritage; a 34-year-old immigrant from Uganda; a former state assemblyman -- winning the New York City mayoral election. He was an unlikely candidate running against a political dynasty, with billionaires wildly throwing millions against him and with barely any support from the Democratic establishment and leadership.
But my doubts were rooted in something bigger than the power brokers lined up against him. Unlike Mamdani, a millennial who was 10 years old in 2001, I was in my late 20s when the horror of 9/11 changed us all and the world around us.
I can viscerally remember the trauma of that day as both an American, fearing for my relatives and fellow Americans who worked in the Twin Towers, and as a Muslim, fearing the backlash against our entire community. A brief moment of unity in the immediate aftermath was followed by years of hateful attacks and targeted policies and harassment. It opened the floodgates for the GOP to use Muslims as their scary bogeyman, especially during an election year, which is when the fears of impending “Shariah law” cynically reappear.
When the anti-Muslim attacks against Mamdani ramped up -- disgusting and dishonest smears that he would cheer another 9/11, that he was a terrorist who should be deported, that he was a threat simply because of his faith -- it tapped into a familiar anxiety among American Muslims in my generation. The bigotry was so open and oddly nonsensical. They called him a radical Islamo-Marxist Communist who would implement Shariah law, even though communism rejects religion and Mamdani has always been openly progressive and liberal.
But I had seen this show before, and I internalized the message: Racist political attacks don’t have to make sense or be connected to reality. They just have to provoke primal emotions of fear and anger to work. Trumpism ascended on the politics of grievance, fear, division and exclusion.
Could this relentlessly positive, charismatic young man talking about compassion and unity and affordability overcome that?
Clearly, he did, and with a mandate that was a stunning rebuke to the fearmongers.
The first Muslim mayor of NYC was elected by a diverse coalition of native-born Americans and immigrants, across religious, ethnic and racial backgrounds. In fact, Brad Lander, the city’s comptroller, a self-described “liberal Zionist” Jew, who grew up in the suburbs of St. Louis, was critical to Mamdani’s success in the primary.
Mamdani’s victory required hundreds of thousands of Jewish voters rejecting the idea that criticism of Israel’s war crimes is antisemitic. It took NYC’s affluent voters recognizing that the city can’t thrive unless its workers can afford to live there. It took New Yorkers who have lived in the city for generations embracing the belief that immigrants make us stronger, and that together we can stand up against an aspiring authoritarian. More than 2 million New Yorkers cast ballots and picked a different vision for the city than it’s ever had.
I don’t know if Mamdani will be able to deliver on all his policy proposals, but I know that running free buses in Kansas City since 2020 hasn’t turned it into a communist hellscape. I know that 50 years of trickle-down economics giving tax cuts and corporate welfare to the wealthiest hasn’t helped the middle class in America. And I can see that sending troops and masked federal agents into American cities against its own citizenry looks like tyranny, not democracy.
I don’t pray as much as I should, but I woke up before dawn on Election Day to say a special prayer. I prayed for better leaders who wanted to serve all their constituents; who believed in the worth and dignity of all people; who wanted to better the lives of the most vulnerable and stand up for justice. I prayed that a majority of New Yorkers would see through the tsunami of lies and bigotry.
When Mamdani was declared the winner with more than 50% of the vote, I felt a kind of hope and optimism that has felt out of reach for years. In his acceptance speech, he said: "I am young ... I am Muslim. I am a democratic socialist. And most damning of all, I refuse to apologize for any of this."
In that moment, I saw a different future of possibilities in this country.
New Yorkers took a chance on a young, untested Muslim man to lead them during these divisive, difficult times, and it healed something deep inside of me.
It felt like a prayer answered, a hope ignited.