DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ll get right to it. I’m 25, male, have never been romantically/physically involved with anybody, and have a crippling fear of rejection. This is all pretty run of the mill, but I’ll explain what the wrinkles are.
I grew up in a country and environment where teenagers didn’t date. It was not a thing that happened and just generally looked down upon. The one time I told a girl I liked her she was quick to let me know that she wasn’t interested, which was enough to keep me in line from that point on. In hindsight this was pretty traumatizing, but I didn’t really put two and two together until very recently. I graduated high school with no dating experience.
I came to America for college and decided to give the whole dating thing a whirl. Freshman year, I went on a couple first dates with girls who weren’t that in to me. This was pretty demoralizing. I never tried dating after that, and ended up spending the rest of my time in college hanging out with a bunch of dudes instead. It was a fun enough time, sure, but that meant me getting another set cap and gown without ever having dated.
That hasn’t changed now that I’m a few years out of college. I am reasonably attractive, am charming enough, and make good money and all that. I’m just deathly afraid of rejection, even when I’m sure that women are flirting with me. I feel like I consciously force myself to “see past” signs that people are attracted to me for fear of messing things up in some way.
For the most part I’ve chosen the constant low-level background unhappiness from being single to the all-at-once emotional bombshell that is being turned down. Obviously, this is unhealthy. I am very American-presenting, so most people don’t expect me to be unfamiliar with American culture. I am afraid that the longer I go without dating, the weirder my lack of experience will seem to potential dates. My knowledge of this should motivate me to put myself out there, but it’s really been having the opposite effect. Part of me irrationally worries that the ship has sailed. In short, how can I drag myself out of this ridiculous feedback loop? Thanks for your help.
Best,
Own-Head Dweller
DEAR OWN-HEAD DWELLER: Readers, I can hear you saying “hang on, didn’t you literally just answer this question? Like, yesterday?” Yes… kind of. Let me take a second to give you a little inside-baseball info here: whenever possible, I like to pair letters that have similar themes, issues or deal with complimentary fears or worries – things that play well together. And with this recent set of letters, we’re seeing two people who’ve had very similar issues and backgrounds, coming together with related-but-distinct problems. And in both cases, while the ultimate solution is very similar, the way they’re resolved is in dealing with the underlying problem rather than the specifics.
OK, so, OHD, I want you to re-read what I said to Solo Leveling Sucks yesterday,s because this applies as much to you as it does to him. The things you’re worried about intimidate you because they’re unfamiliar, that’s all. The key to breaking through this wall you perceive is very simple: you just go out and do it. You resolve that you’re going to power through the feeling of awkwardness and weirdness, ignore the fear that says “this is going to devastate me” and just try. And as I said before: everyone starts from the same place, the only difference between them and you is when you start. Nobody truly gives a f--k when you started, they only care that you got there.
Now, in your case, part of what you’re wrestling with isn’t really the fear of rejection, it’s the fear of how rejection would make you feel. You’re basically afraid of feeling bad. Which, hey, I get it, feeling bad… well, feels bad.
(This sort of stunning insight is why they pay me the tall relationship advice dollar.)
But the funny thing is: the fear of what rejection might feel like is almost always worse than the actual fear. You’ve spent so much time building it up in your head, coming up with all these worst-case scenarios and imagining how it’s going to feel that you’ve built it up into this huge monster of a feeling in your head. And to make matters worse, our brains react to what we imagine as though it were real, so you’ve been making yourself feel all those uncomfortable and painful feelings every time. No wonder that you’re so intimidated by it; as far as your brain’s concerned, you’ve been through this hundreds of times already. Why in pluperfect hell would you willingly put yourself through this again?
Well, because there’s no such thing as a guarantee of success. There’s no dating without the risk of rejection. The possibility of rejection, and rejection itself, is the price you pay for meeting people and wanting to see if you want to date them and if they want to date you. There’s no getting around it. If you want to date, you have to get comfortable with the possibility of rejection. That’s just life.
Just as importantly: there’s no way to get comfortable with the possibility of rejection – or with rejection itself – except to be rejected. It’s like boxing or mixed martial arts: you’re going to get punched and so you’re going to have to learn how to take a punch. And unfortunately, there’s no way to learn how to take a punch and not be afraid of being punched, except to get punched. You just have to face it and learn how to deal with it.
“Well, I don’t want to get punched!” I hear you cry. Which is reasonable. But punching is part of boxing. If you want to get into boxing, you’re gonna get punched. If you don’t want to get punched, you don’t get into boxing.
So it is with dating. Rejection is a part of dating. You’re going to get rejected, because everyone does. Nobody goes 5 for 5, no matter who they are. Doesn’t matter what celebrity you think of, what influencer, model, incredibly hot stranger you see on the street – everyone gets rejected at many points in their lives. You learn to accept it, and you learn to avoid it when you can and you learn to roll with it when it happens.
However, here’s the part you don’t realize yet: rejection is almost always far less painful and far less scary than what you’re picturing in your head. The first couple times can be especially bad, sure, but that’s in part because, well, you have nothing to compare it to and most of the time, you’re overly invested, emotionally, in the outcome than it actually deserves. If you’ve built this person into more than just someone you might like to go on a date with, or someone you’d like to get to know better, then that rejection is going to hurt more because you’ve created a situation where that rejection would hurt more. If you decided that the success or failure of your deepest dreams would be determined by the flip of a coin, you’d be hurt if it didn’t come up tails, like you wanted.
That’s part of why it hurt so much when you got rejected the first time. You never experienced it before, and you almost certainly built the idea of dating her into something more than it should be under the circumstances. When she said “no thank you”, it felt like your world was crashing down because you built your world around her saying yes.
Well, the obvious thing to do going forward is to stop building worlds around people, especially people who you aren’t in a relationship with. They haven’t earned that level of importance and investment yet. They may tick all your boxes; you may be able to easily imagine the incredible time you would have with them… but you still barely know them and you certainly haven’t spent enough time or shared enough together to warrant world-building. Doing so prematurely is how you end up with unnecessary and easily avoidable heart-break.
This is why you want to go into these situations with the mentality of “ok, you’re attractive and I think you’re cool… what else do you have going for you and what makes you right for me?” You want to see asking them out on a date as the first step in simply getting to know whether they’re someone you would like to get to know better. Maybe they’re not right for you! Maybe they like to play tennis with live kittens! Maybe they think JD Vance is an insightful and canny politician! You don’t know! Do you want to spend time with a person like that? Would you feel good about investing in them only to find this out later? No? Well, that’s why you don’t invest so much importance to their “yes” until you know they’re worth investing in!
I hate to say it, but you’re going to have to make the conscious decision to go out and risk being rejected. There really is no way around it. But not only is that how you learn that rejection isn’t as bad as you imagine it to be, but you also learn that you don’t need to be afraid of it, you learn how to deal with it and you learn not to make it worse than it actually is.
There’s no learning without doing. There’s no doing without accepting the risk. But outcome isn’t that bad, and as you date, you also realize that rejection just means this person wasn’t right for you, for whatever reason. It’s not always pleasant, but better to find out they’re not right for you now rather than weeks or months or years down the line.
You’ve made rejection into this big scary thing in your head, OHD, and it’s keeping you from what you want. The only way to really get over this fear is to face it and realize that you’ve blown it out of proportion – both through your imagination and through over-investment in others. Stop building it up in your head, avoid imbuing any one person with more importance than they’ve actually earned, ask some folks out and be ready to face rejection head on.
You’ll realize incredibly quickly that all you’re afraid of is the fear. Overcome that and the rest will start falling into place.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com