DEAR DR. BLONZ: I have tried intermittent fasting, but I want to know your thoughts on going on a multi-day complete fast for energy, cellular renewal, detoxification and immune system strength. Water would not be stopped, only all food. Thanks. -- A.K., Raleigh, North Carolina
DEAR A.K.: The idea of fasting has been around for a long time and is an integral part of many religions. The origins are intertwined with ancient beliefs that fasting leads to a purification of the soul or spirit. I appreciate your qualifying complete fasting from intermittent fasting, where you only eat during specific times or a limited number of hours a day. This is a more nuanced area with varying approaches and evolving research (for more on intermittent fasting, see the article at: b.link/8pp5ue6).
Up front, let's understand that when you stop eating, your supply of energy and raw materials, as well as the rate of tissue repair, all decrease. Glucose (blood sugar) is the preferred fuel for the brain and nervous system. It is the only fuel that the red blood cells use, and it is the body's primary source for instant energy. Glucose allows you to transition from resting to running without first taking deep breaths to increase the level of oxygen in your blood. There are small stores of a form of glucose in the liver and muscles, but it doesn't last very long. When in short supply, the body craves glucose to the point that it breaks down its muscles and organs to get at the specific amino acids it can modify into glucose (glucogenic amino acids).
Daily protein intake provides amino acids to replace worn-out cells, but during a fast, the body must recycle its amino acids. It comes up short because some are recruited to form the needed glucose. During the first days of a fast, approximately 75 grams per day of the body's protein gets used to satisfy our need for glucose; this slows tissue growth and repair.
One of the claimed benefits of fasting is that not eating allows the digestive system to rest, thereby freeing energy to help the body detoxify and improve overall health. This is illogical. Normally, about 10% of dietary energy is used to digest, absorb and metabolize what's in food. Fasting for this purpose would be like quitting your job to save commuting expenses.
As for detox claims, toxins are often fat-soluble compounds that distribute themselves throughout the stored fat in the body while awaiting elimination. With a fast, the mobilization of fat calories can result in increased blood levels of these unwanted substances and contribute to the general weakness experienced. There is much to consider. A healthy diet and lifestyle are important goals, and many paths can take you in that direction. I encourage you to look behind rosy portrayals of total food fasting as critical to that objective.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.