DEAR HARRIETTE: My friend always changes her story when it comes to small things, but I feel like the accumulation of all these small inconsistencies is starting to get to me. For example, she was just talking about how she plans to work at the company we both work at for five more years, but then not even two minutes later, she mentioned wanting to apply to grad school within the next year. It’s hard to keep up when her story changes so frequently, and sometimes I feel like I can’t tell what’s actually true.
It’s not just about work; she does this in other parts of her life, too. One week she’s talking about saving money and being serious about her goals, and the next she’s making impulsive plans that completely contradict what she said before. I don’t think she’s intentionally lying, but it’s starting to make me question her credibility and reliability.
I want to be a supportive friend, but I also don’t want to feel like I’m constantly trying to decode what’s real and what’s not. How can I bring this up without sounding judgmental or confrontational? I care about her, but I’m starting to lose patience. -- Inconsistent
DEAR INCONSISTENT: Sit down with your friend and let her know that she is confusing you. Give her a few examples of things she has passionately told you only to reverse moments later. Tell her it is hard for you to know when she’s serious, as she changes her mind so frequently. Admit that it is frustrating to you. Listen to how she responds.
Ultimately, you may have to back off a bit and not get so invested in her ideas, especially if they are consistently inconsistent. You can listen neutrally, not allow yourself to go down a rabbit hole to help and, instead, just be a sounding board.