DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: I’ve been devouring your content for a while. It’s refreshing to find someone who isn’t from manosphere type spaces. Because of a lot of personal social hardships and traumas I’ve faced, I’ve had a lot of trouble with social connections and dating/sex – some of it was due to mistakes I made, while others were due to discrimination, bullying, and other factors. I’m often insecure about how a lot of people hook up and date in university, but I struggled to even get any positive attention from women no matter how hard I tried. That led me down some dark paths.
Anyway, your content is something I found really valuable about how connection and vulnerability are the bedrocks (pun intended) of sexual or other connections. I’ve also struggled generally with online dating – pretty much no luck at all.
This brings me to my dilemma – due to bullying and discrimination, I often found myself ‘masking’ and shrinking into myself more, becoming afraid to talk about any of my interests in depth, or showing off any traits that could give away that I’m autistic. This was developed over years growing up due to adverse experiences like bullying or negative judgment. I have some friends with whom I gradually open up more. Also, Autistic/neurodiversity advocacy is a big part of my life. However, I’m still often hesitant to share that part of me with people I meet, including women, because I’m terrified of being judged because of stigma. Certain interests of mine are also stereotypically Autistic, like trains, Sonic the Hedgehog, Star Wars, etc.
I’ve seen a lot of valuable videos on how to try and make yourself more approachable, how to be socially calibrated to avoid creeping out women – that’s something I struggled with a lot, in large part due to my anxiety and bitterness consuming me so much it would make me terrified to talk to women and thus be kind of hovering around hesitantly or otherwise coming off as intense (not necessarily in a good way). Of course, I’m also aware of studies of how Autistic people are often quickly judged as less likeable due to snap judgments. Growing up people would often clock me as ‘weird’ or ‘off’.
After a lot of reflection and some of your content I’m realizing the importance of vulnerability and just how much of myself I often keep masked or hidden from others which is a huge hindrance to intimacy in general. But at the same time the fear and stigma and anxiety are rooted so deeply within me as to be nearly paralyzing.
Given the centrality of autism and Autistic advocacy to my life, and how people knowing I’m Autistic can often explain away certain differences, I have to wonder: Is it worth revealing that part of me to women I’m interested in early on? I know the world is more accepting than it once was, but I’m still often bombarded with messages about how shallow people can be and sometimes people do still treat me poorly. At the same time, I can’t help but wonder if me revealing my Autistic identity in my childhood could possibly have stopped the bullying and helped people (including girls) understand me better.
Also, is it a good idea to disclose that on a dating profile? I’ve seen a lot of mixed opinions on that. What’s yours?
The few successful (but very short-lived) sexual interactions I had were with friends who I had fully opened up to, and were often Autistic or neurodivergent themselves. They were all kind of flukes, and not all that great. And I’ve never been in an official relationship – due in part to my strong emotional attachments and dealing with heartbreak poorly and thus becoming afraid to truly like someone. I’m also at a point in my life where I’d probably date more casually, anyway.
I’d love to hear your thoughts/insights if you have any for me.
When Do I Tell?
DEAR WHEN DO I TELL: I’m not surprised that you’re a little gun-shy about telling people you’re autistic, WDIT. It’s an understandable response when folks have hurt you and insulted you and bullied you over something that’s part of what makes you uniquely you. But, like a lot of defense mechanisms, I suspect that this form of protecting yourself isn’t actually meeting your needs. It may have in the past, when your needs and circumstances were different… but it seems pretty clear to me that it’s only hindering you now.
I will freely admit that neurodivergent people face challenges. Our society and culture as it currently stands is, if not actively hostile, at least unaccommodating and unsympathetic to the needs of people who are varying flavors of neurodivergent. The pressure to conform and mask in order to “fit in” and move through the world smoothly is intense. But at the same time, masking and hiding one’s neurodivergence creates more problems than it actually solves.
I’m a believer that hiding this side of yourself is a poor choice. It may be a necessary one at times – the best of a bad set of options – but one that ultimately works against you and your overall goals in a number of important ways. Being open about who you are, while challenging and often intimidating, is going to be better in terms of advancing what you want in both society and in your personal life.
On the macro level, a lot of the stigma against autism and neurodivergence is based out of ignorance and stereotypes. Even supposedly “good” stereotypes regarding autistic people are dehumanizing; they’re more akin reducing a person to particular traits or (worse) to “party tricks” instead of as individuals. Much of it comes from other people speaking for (and over) autistic people, denying them agency and individuality, rather of listening or letting autistic people advocate for themselves. That lets neurotypical people set the terms and – importantly – set expectations for how “real” autistic people behave and “should” be treated.
(And goes a long way towards treating neurodivergence as something to be “cured”, I might add, instead of just being how someone is.)
Being open and up front about being autistic forces people to see the person and not the stereotype. It makes someone an individual, with their own quirks, flaws and features, rather than part of a nameless, faceless collection of issues and “problems” – a one-size-fits-all description that sands away any variance or uniqueness and encourages people to see all autistic folks one way.
People tend to be more accepting and understanding and change their views when they realize that someone they know and love is autistic; they see the person, not the archetype they’re told to expect.
But being open is important on the individual level too, in no small part because it gives context to an individual and who they are. It helps round out people’s picture of the person in front of them – who they are, why they behave the way they do and so on. That context is pretty important when it comes to relationships – platonic and sexual.
After all, masking may make things easier in terms of surface level acceptance and fitting in, but it hinders actual connection and relationships. You may be concealing aspects of yourself that you worry will turn off others, but it doesn’t convey the ability to overcome those challenges. If you have ADHD, you still struggle with short-term memory and focus. If you have BPD, you still deal with emotional self-regulation and ideation. If you’re autistic, you have issues regarding overwhelm, reading social cues and so on. These can all cause issues within relationships, and without that context, it can create misunderstandings and conflicts where those conflicts don’t need to exist.
Speaking for myself, my particular flavor of neurodivergence (ADHD), meant I spent decades of teachers and authority figures thinking I just wasn’t “disciplined” enough or didn’t work hard enough or didn’t take things seriously. The way ADHD f--ked with my memory and ability to pay attention meant people thought I was careless or unconcerned or even so self-involved that I didn’t think of others. If I’d had my diagnosis as a child and the attendant label, it would’ve changed the context of how people saw me – instead of being someone who couldn’t be bothered to do the work, I would’ve been someone who was struggling and needed support. It would have opened up access to resources and help and alternate ways of accomplishing the same tasks. It would also have encouraged people to be a little more understanding and made it easier to find ways to overcome the inconveniences and frustrations that came with the way my brain worked.
The same goes with being open about being autistic. There’re things that, without the context of being autistic, that people will misunderstand. They may think you’re being “picky” or “overly sensitive” or “deliberately obtuse” and “stubborn”. They may wonder why you ignore them, why you seem so distracted or never seem to listen to what they’re saying. They won’t realize that maybe you’re overstimulated and trying to contain it, that you’re stimming or that you simply aren’t getting an implied message because it’s all subtext and implication that you simply don’t grasp. But if they knew, the two of you would have more paths towards mutual understanding, ways of figuring out how the two of you can relate to one another and how to avoid unnecessary conflicts.
And just on the functional side of things, owning that you’re autistic means that you’re better able to ask for what you need. You’re not neurotypical, so trying to date like you are is going to be like swimming upstream. It’s possible, if you’re really determined to do it, but it’s going to take at least twice as much effort to go half as far and you’re going to exhaust yourself in the process. Owning being autistic and being open about it means that you can advocate for what you actually need, in the moment.
If you feel like there’s a message you’re not picking up because it’s all indirect or subtext, you can say “Hey, I feel like I’m missing subtext here, please just be blunt with me.” Or you can say “I don’t understand that” instead of spending time trying to puzzle through it via context clues. The same goes with dating and flirting – telling people specifically what works for you makes it a lot easier for them to connect with you and vice versa.
But making it work means that you have to treat this information like “here’s how you win with me”, not as “here, let me reveal my secret shame.” If you treat it like you’re revealing a generational curse the Goblin King imposed on your ancestor or some horrible flaw about you, then not only are you setting the tone for how other people are going to receive this information, but you’re setting the tone for how you expect to be seen. That sense of “allow me to apologize for this aspect of myself” goes both ways; it encourages a mindset where you are seeing it in the same negative light as others.
If, on the other hand, you’re treating it as simple data – “this is part of who I am, this is how best to interact with me” – then it’s just that: information. It gives them valuable data about how they can connect with you, share with you and ensure that you’re both able to really communicate clearly and correctly. That in and of itself is helpful and useful!
But it also affects how they see you, because you’re putting things into context and shaping their expectations. Being open about being autistic is telling them “this is part of what makes me the specific person I am.” And if you like who you are, if you embrace it as part of what makes you unique and special, then sharing that information the same way – “this is what makes me awesome” – encourages other people to see it the same way. ��It frames all of the little things that make you uniquely you in a good way. It’s a little like how people can have these seemingly minor things about them that we find to be especially endearing or special about them – the way her lips quirk when she’s trying not to laugh, the way he keeps singing incorrect lyrics to this popular song, their unusual favorite foods or the way their eyes light up when they get a chance to talk about their favorite topic. Sure, there’re things that are also occasionally annoying – this person hates particular textures in their food or on their skin, that person has a tendency to sing little snatches of nonsense songs when they concentrate – but those, too, become part of what we adore about them; the little irritations we realize we miss when they’re gone because it’s just part of who they are.
By concealing those aspects of yourself under the aegis of “nobody must know of my shame”, you’re hiding away the little things that people would think of fondly when you they think of you. That just seems like a shame to me, especially when you (the general “you”, not you specifically WDIT) treat them like things to be ashamed of when they aren’t.
Now, will being open about being autistic mean that some folks just won’t rock with you? Yeah, of course. Putting it in your dating profile means that some folks are going to see it and nope out before they even reach the next punctuation in that sentence.
And that’s a good thing. That’s precisely the what you want people to do, because you don’t want to date those people. If someone would treat you poorly because you’re open about being autistic, then why the pluperfect hell would you want them in your lives in the first place?
I mean, for the sake of argument, let’s say that you get so good at masking that you pass for neurotypical most of the time, and you end up in a relationship with someone who doesn’t know that you’re autistic. You haven’t told them yet, but you intend to… and then you hear the comments they make about another autistic person and how they seem to hold all autistic people in contempt.
Do you really want to be in a relationship with someone who sees this fundamental aspect of who you are – something that you are as responsible for and as much control over as the color of your eyes – as an unforgivable flaw? Someone who thinks of your whole, holistic self as something that needs to be corrected or cured, regardless of how you might feel on the matter? Someone who may think it makes you less of a person?
That sort of heartbreak is worse than if they rejected you from the jump. You would never have wanted to date them in the first place if you knew that about them. But now you’ve spent this time – whether it’s months or even weeks – investing in them, building a connection and planning for a future together… only to find out that she would toss all of that aside over something that’s a core part of you as an individual. Something about you that shapes every aspect of who you are, how you see the world around you and how you move through it… and she thinks it’s horrible and needs to be fixed.
That is far worse than if you filtered her out of your dating pool before you ever got to that point.
Yeah, I will freely admit that the process of getting to that point is hard. Knowing that you’re inviting rejection from folks who might actually be a good match otherwise is rough, especially when it’s out of ignorance rather than malice. And when you feel like you have a hard time meeting people already, it’s hard to say “ok, lemme restrict my results even further.”
But I can tell you from experience: you get far better outcomes when you focus on meeting the people who are right for you rather than trying to cast the widest net possible. Broad appeal is shallow appeal, and it means spending more time dealing with people who simply are wrong for you. As hard as it is to believe: it’s better be lonely because you’re alone than it is to be lonely because you’re with the wrong person. Being alone can be fixed. Being lonely because you’re with someone who you shouldn’t be with wrecks your soul.
So overall, yes, I think it’s best to be open and up front about being autistic. I think you should be willing to date like you are autistic instead of trying to force yourself into being neurotypical. Not only will it help, but I think it’ll be an important part of healing the wounds you’re carrying around. Loving yourself to embrace and live your truth is going to be a deliberate and calculated rejection of all the folks who bullied you and hurt you and told you that your existence was a flaw. So f--k ‘em all right in the ear.
You are who you are, and you should live like it, love like it and be loved for it.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com