DEAR DR. NERDLOVE: First, the exposition. The backdrop is not extraordinary these days; I’m facing down a really rough job market and the stress of big transitions in my life that really serves to complicate my perception of how much stress I SHOULD be feeling, all the while trying to work to turn my mental health around. I’ve made a lot of big steps forward, building up my social and professional network, but I still feel very stuck romantically, for reasons I deeply struggle to articulate. Practically, I feel like I find precious few opportunities in my day-to-day to find a partner, and apps like Bumble or Hinge net me a few conversations per year, and if I’m lucky, I’ll get a date that goes fine, but never more than that. There’s the concern about finishing my degree in a month or so and having to deal with a huge logistical shift with uncertain financial and social prospects, and all that feels like it’s to be expected, and I can account for it, more or less.��However, there’s a deeper pit of something I feel is really causing me a lot of pain, and very likely gets in my way when it comes to searching for a romantic partner, and has for 15 years. As I stated before, it’s really hard to articulate, and encompasses a lot of past trauma, self-esteem issues, and a whole bunch more that I haven’t been able to work out. I feel that I have plenty of great qualities that should make me attractive to a potential partner, and even one that I would be mutually attracted to. I’ve been out of the game so long I can’t be very articulate about what specifically I’m looking for, or what kind of person I want to be with, but it’s a “know it when I see it” sort of thing. Despite that, I have immense difficulty in truly believing that other people are or might be attracted to me. It’s something I haven’t felt (or maybe haven’t let myself feel) for just about half of my life now, and, to put it simply, I really get in my head about it.��As a recent point, I have a female friend I’ve had for a while, and the other day I sent her a message briefly explaining that while I’m not sure about anything, I have some type of feelings for her, and wanted to be up front about it, since we’ve been getting closer than I’ve been with a female friend in a long time: talking frequently, hanging out with just the two of us, etc. I figured it was an opportunity to ask for some sort of clarity regarding just how she sees me as a friend, since I’m very insecure about my own judgment on that sort of thing. While I’m fairly certain I brought it up in a reasonably appropriate, non-threatening sort of way, and I don’t really think I’ve done anything inappropriate or crossed a line, ever since I sent her that message, I’ve had this underlying feeling that hearkens back to my first breakup, 15 years ago, when I feel like I went completely overboard in seeking clarification as to my relationship with this person who I still wanted to at least consider a friend, and long story short, led to a few years of severe late teenage angst and depression that ultimately ended any hope of friendship, and left me feeling deeply guilty about not only the way I acted, but even how I felt.��To answer the question that I’m sure you’ve already formulated, I’m currently seeing a therapist, and have been for almost a year now, and this is what I really wanted to get a vibe check on. (yes, all the previous has been preamble, I apologize) I’ve tried to do therapy a number of times over the years, and while it has been very helpful in certain ways, there are things that I feel I’ve never really been able to dig to the bottom of, and I’m unsure if it’s a problem with me not doing my part, or not finding the right therapist. To be specific, I saw my first therapist weekly for about a year, I saw one every other week for a few months, one weekly through last summer, and I’ve been working with my current therapist weekly since October or so. It’s not in my nature to blame external factors when I can blame myself, which is easy to do when every week my appointment rolls around, and I find myself unable to articulate the things I’m really deeply struggling with, either not being able to find the words, or self-censoring out of a habitual suppression of emotions I’ve deemed to be harmful, and I’m not sure which. I also understand that healing is a slow process, but feel that between thinking on it and working myself, and the work I’ve done with therapists, I’m still feeling the same things now at 31 that I felt when I was 16 and f--king things up for myself.��To put it into a distinct question that’s appropriate to ask someone who’s NOT my therapist, how can I tell if I need to push through my hesitancy and be more honest with my therapist, or if that hesitancy is something I need to find a better therapist to help me push through? As I said, my predisposition is to always blame myself first before blaming others, but I find it hard to know if I’m not getting where I want to be because I’m not getting the help I need from my therapist, or if I need to do more work to allow them to give me the help I need. There’s also the tendency I have to downplay the things I’m struggling with, and feel like they’re somehow petty concerns that I shouldn’t still be dwelling on, or that focusing on how lonely I’ve been for 15 years and continue to feel is harmful and I need to avoid thinking like that. It’s as though no matter how many times I’m told “this is a safe space”, I’m still unable to voice some feelings, not just because I’m used to suppressing them, but also because I’m deeply resistant to letting myself share these feelings that hurt me and my first relationship all those years ago, because it feels like undoing progress I’ve made (or convinced myself I’ve made).��It is, of course, not a fast process, and after struggling for a decade and a half, I’m certainly eager to see more results, but I also don’t want to let my rather high capacity for patience leave me unhealed and loveless for another 15-20 years. I already lost the opportunity for love during my 20s, and am still processing that. I really don’t want this to be a major pastime for me throughout my life.��Regards,�-It’s Not You, It’s Me
Advertisement
DEAR IT’S NOT YOU IT’S ME: Can I ask you an honest question, INYIM: are you sure the problem isn’t that you don’t know how to express what you’re feeling but that you’re so worried about actually saying it that you dump endless qualifiers and context into everything, turning every sentence into a marathon?
I’m not dunking on you for s--ts and giggles, especially as I am the king of “why use one word when you can use six instead?” I think you’re trying way too hard to avoid any possibility of conflict or someone getting upset at you that it gets int the way of actually communicating. You’re filling up space with so much that it stops being information and starts being noise. There’s wanting to make sure you have sufficient context and information and then there’s the point where the actual information is lost in a slurry of “please don’t be mad at me”.
Your asking your friend for clarity is a prime example. You drop nearly 300 words to describe a situation without actually conveying any meaningful information, when you could’ve just said “I told a friend I think I may have a crush on her and wanted to find out if she was on the same page. Now I’m worried I f--ked up, somehow”. 99% of what you threw into that very long sentence could’ve been cut and made things far clearer. Instead, it’s a long and ramble-y journey that ultimately goes nowhere.
If I’m being perfectly honest, I think this is as much about you as it is about whomever you’re trying to communicate with.
This isn’t the first letter I’ve gotten this year from someone who’s been unwilling – not unable, unwilling– to actually open up to their therapist about how they’re feeling and what they’re dealing with, and they tend to fall in very similar patterns. Lots of explaining, lots of qualifiers, but it’s all ultimately the verbal equivalent of flack, trying to keep people from actually seeing or reaching the target. It’s the same sort of emotional self-defense, but also self-flagellation, trying to intellectualize away the fear of just being honest and vulnerable.
I’m wondering if part of the problem isn’t that you don’t know what you want or aren’t sure how to articulate the issue so much as you don’t let yourself actually answer the question. Reading through this – which I had to do multiple times, by the way – I get the distinct impression that you’re ultimately trying to hide how you really feel from yourself, and I think you need to dig into that.
And to be fair: I get that. I’ve had break ups where I wanted to “be the bigger person” and “be mature and reasonable about this” and tried to pretend that I wasn’t angry about the break up or that I felt it wasn’t fair or handled badly. But because I wanted to maintain this idea that I was handling things “the right way”, I tried my damnedest to convince myself I wasn’t feeling those things, even though I absolutely was. Needless to say, that meant that I was carrying around a lot of feelings that I refused to acknowledge, never mind deal with, and that kept me from moving on the way I should have.
But making matters worse is that this all seems to stem from s--t that happened when you were 16. I get that high-school relationships have more drama than the Royal Shakespeare Society but there comes a point where you have to recognize that it was high-school. Everyone’s a goddamn mess in high-school and anyone who says that they had it all figured out is either lying or deluding themselves.
You need to be willing to say “yeah, I did some stupid s--t because I was a teenager and didn’t know wat the hell I was doing,” and let it go. Was it embarrassing? Of course. Was it cringe? Naturally; our teenage years are made of cringe. Cringe is what happens when you’re stuck in a space where you’re expected to be an adult without the rights or privileges or even brain development of one, but still treated as a child regardless. But part of growing up is being able to look back and go “Damn that was awkward but I see how I ended up there”, not “this is going to define me for the rest of my life”.
You’re clearly trying very hard to intellectualize things that shouldn’t be intellectualized, as though that’s going to change the feelings themselves. So maybe you need to stop trying to change things or pretend that you’re not feeling them and just let yourself feel them. And I mean just feel them – no qualifiers, no context-clarification, no “ok but…”. Just finally lower the shield, open the flood gates and let that s--t out. You’ve let this emotional wound get infected and now you need to drain the pus before you can disinfect it and close it back up.
So yes, you’re not making progress with your therapist precisely because you’re not actually participating in your therapy. The whole point of therapy is that you’re talking to someone who is there to listen to you without judgment, secure in the knowledge that nothing you say leaves that room. It is the place for emotional vomit, to just open your mouth and let the firehose go, giving voice to those feelings that you’ve been trying to tamp down. Yes, even the petty s--t, the inconsequential s--t, the s--t that you think is so banal that you don’t think it’s worth the bother to bring up. Because, let’s be real here: we’ve long established that maybe you’re not the best judge about whether this is inconsequential, petty s--t after all.
Instead, all you’ve done is try to push them away and pretend they don’t exist. This just serves to pressurize the entire mess, compacting them into something denser, more intense and more likely to break containment.
So here’s what you need to do: you need to get a pen and a notebook and just start writing. No thinking, no editing, no intellectualizing, no trying to make it coherent or sensible or to minimize it. Just open the valve in your brain and let it spill out through your pen onto paper in its rawest form. No agenda, no “today I’m going to write about my feelings on Z”, just dumping every single thought you have out exactly as you have it in that moment.
And yes, I mean write, by hand, on physical media, not typing or dictating. You want this to be as pure brain-vomit as possible, with no stops or pauses or barriers. Writing it out long-hand is as direct a connection between brain and output as you can get without literally wiring your brain up to a recording device that can turn theta waves into language.
Do this daily from now until your next appointment with your therapist. Then take your journal with you to your therapy appointment and say “ok, I’ve been having problems opening up and saying what I really feel”, then show them this.
If you still have an issue with expressing how you feel or figuring it out, write it down with as few words as possible. You want to be Hemmingway, not Faulkner. You’re not trying to paint a picture, you’re trying to communicate, and you’ve been using verbal noise as a barrier. Now it’s time to distill everything down to its essence and deal with the actual issue, not all the mental equivalent of artificial colors and flavoring to make it more “palatable”. Bring those with you and read them, out loud, to your therapist. Then actually listen to what they say and try taking it on board. It’s going to be hard because, up until now, you’ve been trying your best to never let anyone know what you’re feeling and now you’re going to feel ashamed and judged. You need to be willing to let that all go and just be raw and vulnerable because, quite frankly, you’ve put this off for far too long and that hasn’t helped at all.
I’m always saying: if you want things to be different, you have to do things differently. You’ve been doing the same thing for over a decade now and it has only made things worse. It’s time to shift gears, stop running from the fear of what’s going to happen if you actually face these feelings and get ready to embrace the suck. Because it will suck. But it’s the same sort of pain that comes from draining an abscess, disinfecting it and stitching it closed. Until you’re willing to do that, it’s just going to continue to fester and rot and expand until the infection takes the rest of you.
You’ve been living with this for long enough. It’s time to let it out and let it go.
Good luck.
Please send your questions to Dr. NerdLove at his website (www.doctornerdlove.com/contact); or to his email, doc@doctornerdlove.com