DEAR DR. BLONZ: I recently read an article about the cancer risks associated with cooking food on the grill, but I have always wondered if these same cautions apply to both charcoal and gas BBQs. We are fortunate enough to be able to use our gas grill year-round. -- V.M., Oakland, California
DEAR V.M.: Cancer stems from a "mistake" in a cell's DNA, the inherited genetic blueprint that tells a cell what to do. Substances that alter genes fall into two categories: mutagens cause genetic changes that may or may not lead to cancer; carcinogens alter genes in ways known to cause cancer. While the human immune system is specifically designed to locate and destroy mutagens and cancerous changes before they get the upper hand, they're nothing to be trifled with.
The issues with barbecue or grilling dangers come from two fronts. Heat and flame hitting the food can cause the formation of mutagens. Next, fats dripping on the hot surface can break down into mutagens and carcinogens, which travel back up to the food with the smoke. Given this scenario, it makes little difference whether the heat comes from charcoal, heated lava rock or directly from a gas flame. The adjustable nature of the gas flame might be considered an asset, as it could be modified periodically to prevent flare-ups and ensure an optimum cooking temperature.
Most forms of high-heat cooking can cause changes in food. With grilling, there tends to be more of those changes, so it's prudent to keep your exposure to a minimum. There are also ways to reduce the risk. Here are a few suggestions: Plan ahead, extend cooking times and keep temperatures more moderate by controlling air flow. The lower the heat, the less smoke and charring. You can limit the time spent on the grill -- with minimal impact on flavor -- by pre-cooking foods in a conventional or microwave oven. Other options are to use indirect heat, rather than cooking the food directly over the heat source. You can also have a pan between the food and the flame to catch or divert the drippings before they hit the heat source. Using marinades can also reduce mutagen formation.
That said, occasional grilling, which I enjoy, should not be a source of great concern. It's yet another reason for healthy eating, given that whole plant foods evolved with substances that protect against unwanted cellular changes, and they can work for us as well.
One final perspective: If you are worrying about eating the food on the grill while sitting outside in the sun, unprotected by sunscreen, or are smoking, eating an unhealthy diet, have an inactive, stress-laden lifestyle or drink alcohol to excess, your priorities are all wrong. And keep the kids away from the grill. All things considered, there's a far greater risk of getting burned than getting cancer. For more on the topic, see the article at b.link/eyzjt8z.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.