DEAR DR. BLONZ: Is there any concern about the different forms of ascorbic acid in many vitamin C supplements, that some are not the best form for the body? I read that rose hips should be used for vitamin C. Is this correct? I have tried, without much luck, to find a chewable vitamin C supplement with rose hips as the source of vitamin C. Does it really matter? Thanks. -- S.T., Raleigh, North Carolina
DEAR S.T.: The design of marketing is to motivate customers to select their product over the competition's. Always be a consumer who checks things out. Rose hips are one of the richest natural sources of vitamin C. Because it is relatively costly, however, it is doubtful that you will find a vitamin C supplement that relies exclusively on rose hips. A careful read of labels will reveal that supplements claiming to be "rose hips vitamin C" are really vitamin C with a little bit of rose hips tossed in for good measure (and label appeal). The same goes for acerola cherries and Camu Camu, other rich natural sources of vitamin C. Besides, whether it comes from rose hips, acerola cherries, an orange or a laboratory, vitamin C is vitamin C, and it is all ascorbic acid.
One benefit of having a natural source for the vitamin C supplement, at least in theory, would be the non-vitamin nutrients and phytochemicals that are present with the naturally occurring vitamin. I qualified this with an "in theory" because you would need to check the label or manufacturer information to verify if any other desirable substance is present at a sufficient level to provide a benefit. Read more about vitamin C at b.link/r2nvm2g.
DEAR DR. BLONZ: I have had a leaded crystal decanter of very expensive Cognac on the shelf for many years. When taking it out at a party, a guest told me not to have more than a sip because lead crystals are dangerous to your health. I know that lead is dangerous, but wanted your opinion as to whether I need to dispose of this wonderful Cognac brandy. -- S.A., Dover, Delaware
DEAR S.A.: Consider this a cautionary note, especially where the fate of your world-class Cognac is concerned. But storage in a leaded crystal decanter will give rise to elevated concentrations of lead, and lead is most certainly dangerous to one's health. Safety dictates that one should not store liquids in leaded crystal glasses or bottles, or drink from such liquids on a daily basis (this would especially be the case if one is pregnant).
Finally, don't feed an infant or child from a leaded crystal baby bottle or cup. The decision of whether to dispose of your Cognac is yours. The body is capable of eliminating lead, but unfortunately, this process is slow. Lead poisoning occurs when the rate of intake exceeds the rate of removal. When drinking a liquid stored in leaded glass, you get a dose of lead with every sip. The longer a liquid sits in a leaded glass, the greater the amount of lead that can leech into the liquid. The alcohol in Cognac, along with the fact that it is slightly acidic, speeds up this process. The increased cut-glass surface area of those classic containers exacerbates all this. How much lead your body can tolerate is a discussion you should have with your physician. Consider buying a lead test kit -- good to have one in the house. For more on lead poisoning, see b.link/cq39597.
Send questions to: "On Nutrition," Ed Blonz, c/o Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. Send email inquiries to questions@blonz.com. Due to the volume of mail, personal replies cannot be provided.