DEAR DR. FOX: I expect you have gotten dozens (at least) letters regarding L.O. in Florida. Though tempted, I will not stoop to her level and call her names. I think, however, she is an example of someone who, at heart, is not really a cat person, and maybe not even an animal person, since her convenience seems to be first and foremost in her mind. At her age, she is unlikely to change.
Long ago, I worked for a vet who very rarely, and only in exceptional situations, would consider declawing a cat. How rarely? There was only one done in the four years I worked for him. I will not go into why he agreed to it that one time, but I was assisting during that operation.
I think anyone who is thinking about having a cat declawed should watch a video of how it is done. It is brutal and bloody. I don’t know if people are simply ignorant or if they do not care, but they need to understand that it is equivalent to amputating all 10 of their fingers at the last joint. Since cats are quadrupeds, the effect is also equivalent to doing the same amputation of all 10 of a human’s toes. While a person could manage to function, to some degree, if this was done, no one would be so callous as to suggest that everything would be just “fine” or “normal” after the procedure if done to a human.
I also wonder if the same people who routinely declaw cats are also in favor of declawing dogs who scratch or are diggers. It is done, unfortunately, as I understand, but not as often. Most people seem more willing to work on training their dogs, keeping their nails trimmed and filed, and either fencing off no-dig areas or keeping their dogs on leashes when outdoors rather than routinely mutilating their feet for their own convenience. Why aren’t cats given the same consideration?
In my 65+ years, I have had many, many cats and have never even been tempted to declaw one of them. I have provided them with various types of scratchers and even trained them on their use when they did not “get it” on their own. I have trimmed and filed nails. I have used nail caps. Yes, I have still had furniture scratched, and I have been scratched more than once myself. I have also had chewers (cats and dogs) and been bitten, but I have not yet stooped to having an animal’s teeth removed to solve that problem.
If a person is not prepared for all that comes with sharing a home with a pet, maybe they should stick to cuddling up with a big, soft plushie instead of trying to surgically modify an animal to suit their preferences.
Thanks for letting me vent. -- K.D., Sebastopol, California
DEAR K.D.: Many thanks for your contribution about this detestable mutilation of cats. Many countries and states have banned declawing of cats due to its harmful nature. Declawing is banned in at least 42 countries, several U.S. states, and 9 out of the 10 Canadian provinces.
Your own personal experience witnessing this surgical procedure is a wake-up call that all cat owners and would-be cat owners should consider whenever a veterinarian in the U.S. suggests it be done while the kitten is anesthetized for spay/neuter.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)