DEAR DR. FOX: You have written about the "empathy deficit disorder" in your columns, and I wanted to alert you to this: Michael Ventura, the author of "Applied Empathy: The New Language of Leadership," wrote a New York Times article on May 4 called "The Dark Side of Empathy."
Advertisement
Here are some excerpts from his article:
“In an interview this year with Joe Rogan, Elon Musk quipped that 'the fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy.' He seemed to blame it, in part, for the decline of America’s cultural vitality. ...
“In psychological terms, empathy is not a singular skill -- it comes in different forms. As researchers have shown, affective empathy (the ability to feel what others feel) is distinct from cognitive empathy (the ability to understand what others feel). Many people have both. Others, like narcissists and sociopaths, often possess only the cognitive sort, if they have empathy at all. And this is where things can get dangerous. ...
“Empathy that connects, that builds, that heals requires a code of ethics. It requires restraint. It requires trust. It asks the empathizer not just to understand others but also to honor what that understanding unlocks. When empathy becomes unmoored from ethics, it becomes coercion with a smile.” -- P.S., San Francisco
DEAR P.S.: I appreciate you (and several other readers) alerting me to this article. Ventura’s analysis is highly relevant socially and politically, but I have a fundamental disagreement with his thesis. I do not believe there is a “dark side” to empathy because where there is empathic sensitivity, ethical sensibility arises spontaneously, as per the golden rule. My book “Bringing Life to Ethics: Global Bioethics for a Humane Society” details this connection.
Empathy involves feeling the pain or emotional state of others, while sympathy simply acknowledges others’ pain or emotional state. It is from the latter that sympathetic manipulation and coercion arise, which Ventura mistakenly regards as the “dark side” of empathy -- rather than the empathy deficit disorder evident in pathological narcissists and sociopaths.
CATTLE IMPORTS HALTED AT SOUTHERN BORDER
The USDA has suspended imports of live cattle, horses and bison at the southern border due to the spread of New World Screwworm, which has been detected as far north as Oaxaca and Veracruz, Mexico. When the parasitic fly larvae burrow into animals’ flesh, "they often cause deadly damage" to livestock, wild animals and pets. Rarely, they also affect birds and humans. (Full story: KSHB-TV, May 12)
All imports, traffic and trade of live animals, wild and domesticated -- except for conservation purposes with effective quarantine precautions -- should be prohibited in the interest of public health.
USDA VETERINARY SERVICES STAFF SLASHED
The Veterinary Services unit in the USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service has lost more than 20% of its employees, including 13 of 23 area veterinarians. The staff reductions coincide with ongoing challenges such as the outbreak of highly pathogenic avian influenza and the threat from New World Screwworm, potentially slowing response times and affecting disease control efforts.
“We won’t know the full impacts of these changes immediately,” said New Mexico State Veterinarian Samantha Holeck. “The important thing is that we work together as a team through all of these challenges.” (Full story: Reuters.com, May 12)
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)