DEAR READERS: Please see this writeup from PetFoodIndustry.com regarding an upcoming industry convention. Angelique Myburgh, a development specialist at Montego Pet Nutrition, will discuss the suitability of South African game meat as a protein source for pets.
Advertisement
Myburgh spoke with Lisa Cleaver of PFI ahead of the conference. Cleaver writes:
"As pet food manufacturers seek sustainable protein alternatives, African game meat from South Africa -- with its rich nutrient profile and eco-friendly production practices -- is emerging as a promising solution for enhancing pet nutrition while supporting sustainable development initiatives. ...
"As a novel protein, African game meat offers hypoallergenic properties, making it ideal for pets with dietary sensitivities to traditional meat proteins.
"'Because these animals roam freely and feed on natural vegetation, the meat is organic and free from artificial additives,' added Myburgh." (For details, see petfoodindustry.com/news-newsletters/pet-food-news/article/15739400/african-game-meat-emerges-as-a-sustainable-protein-for-pet-food.)
DR. FOX HERE: I say expanding our exploitation and killing of wildlife for commercial purposes, including pet foods, is ethically and ecologically untenable.
Two examples that should be curbed: kangaroo meat, which is an increasingly popular protein source in Australian pet food, and venison. Using venison in pet foods poses the risk of spreading chronic wasting disease, along with lead poisoning from hunters’ lead shot.
Dogs thrive on properly formulated vegan foods. A study conducted by PLOS One found that dogs on vegan diets had fewer health issues than those on conventional meat diets. (See "Vegan versus meat-based dog food: Guardian-reported indicators of health" by Andrew Knight et al., published in PLOS One in 2022.)
Dogs, like us, are flexible omnivores and do not need meat. Both dogs and people can thrive on vegan and vegetarian diets. Companies like Wild Earth, Evolution Diet and V-Dog are producing fully plant-based offerings for dogs, and the movement is gaining momentum.
Vegan cat foods, however, are not biologically appropriate because cats are obligate carnivores: They need meat. Until the production of cultivated meats via cellular bio-fermentation scales up and is affordable for manufacturers, they must rely on animal sources. Often, those sources are discards from factory pig, beef, poultry and fish farming systems -- the output deemed unfit for human consumption. (The inclusion of nutrients from farmed insects in pet and human foods, as a more humane and ecologically regenerative resource, is yet to expand.)
Cat owners indirectly support these inhumane animal industries; many are aware of the dilemma and desire an alternative. There is an opportunity here for cat food manufacturers to facilitate the processing of humanely raised animals -- fed organically certified foods and not given antibiotics and other production-enhancing drugs -- into their products. My veterinary and environmental health colleagues are calling for increased corporate responsibility in protein sourcing for cats.
Choosing instead to include wild game in pet foods endorses unsustainable "wildlife farming" practices. Harvesting wildlife, including sea life, contributes to climate change and biodiversity loss, and it must end. The economically driven scale of exploitation is not ecologically sustainable or regenerative.
(Send all mail to animaldocfox@gmail.com or to Dr. Michael Fox in care of Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106. The volume of mail received prohibits personal replies, but questions and comments of general interest will be discussed in future columns.
Visit Dr. Fox’s website at DrFoxOneHealth.com.)