DEAR HARRIETTE: My adult daughters absolutely refuse to call or visit their father, and it’s become a constant point of tension in our family. I’m still married to him, and while they love me, they make it clear they want nothing to do with him. They grew up watching me handle almost everything in the household all while working full time. Meanwhile, their dad was emotionally distant and rarely helpful, and he often acted like any family responsibility was an inconvenience. Now that they’re older, they tell me that he’s selfish and that I deserve better. They insist I should divorce him and “start fresh,” but they don’t understand how complicated that feels at my age. I’ve spent decades with this man. I don’t want to be lonely, and I don’t want to divide the family even further, but the idea of starting over is overwhelming. At the same time, I’m tired of being stuck in the middle. My daughters think I’m making excuses for him, and my husband gets defensive whenever I bring up their feelings.
I feel like I’m being pulled in two different directions: loyalty to the man I built a life with and loyalty to my daughters who only want what they think is best for me. How do I navigate this without alienating either side? How do I make peace with the fear of being alone if I’m starting to wonder whether my daughters might actually be right? -- In the Middle
DEAR IN THE MIDDLE: Your adult daughters can make their own choices about how they interact with their father as long as they are respectful. They cannot force you to do anything. You should assess your life carefully and decide what you want for your later years. It may be scary to leave, but would that be best? If so, plot it out. If not, make peace with what you have. Thank your daughters for their concern, but let them know you have to live your own life.