DEAR HARRIETTE: I was riding the subway during an off-peak hour. There were a few other passengers in my train car but still a lot of empty seats. A few stops into my ride, a seemingly unhoused person got onto my train, and as he sat down, four or five people got up and switched their seats to move away from him. I was already on the other end of the car, but I saw it all happen. This person then got up and snapped at everyone, yelling, “I’m a person, too.” It was quite sad to see. While I didn’t do it that day, I’m guilty of having moved away from certain people in the past. What can we do to be more mindful of how we treat others in circumstances like this? -- Be the Change
DEAR BE THE CHANGE: A great humanizer in a large city with public transportation is that you will be in the company of people who live in a variety of circumstances that may be different from your own. It can be easy to ignore them or attempt to distance yourself from them, especially in crowded areas, but as you witnessed, people notice when others back away.
Does that mean those people should have stayed in their seats? Not necessarily. If someone enters your space -- on the train or elsewhere -- and their smell or demeanor is unsettling, you have the right to move. You can even move just because you want more room if someone sits next to you and crowds you. What you should do, however, is to tap into your humanity first. If you have something to offer such as a piece of fruit or a bottle of water and the person is obviously in distress, quietly offer it. Let your attitude be one that shows that you honor the dignity in the other person, even if you move away.