A 27-year-old physical therapist from Phoenix has housing ambitions he’s yet to disclose to the girlfriend he’s dated since college. He intends to propose, but only after buying a house where the two could live. The plan is very doable but for one challenge: his tight budget.
“In my profession you don’t make a ton of money. So I really have to shop cautiously and not overspend. The good news is that there are lots of houses for sale in the Phoenix area, and list prices are falling slightly. That makes me optimistic,” he says.
The physical therapist currently has his eye on multiple properties, including one move-in ready townhouse in Gilbert, Arizona, where he grew up. The townhouse is listed for $460,000, but the seller promises to offer a substantial credit toward a buyer’s closing costs.
“This house is practically new and loaded with builder upgrades, including the best granite countertops and luxe bathrooms. Also, it’s located in a walkable neighborhood with good restaurants,” he says.
Even so, this buyer is still surveying the market and keeping his options open without yet submitting any bids.
“It’s very obvious Phoenix is now a buyer’s market. I want to take advantage. That’s why there’s no need to rush,” he says.
Real estate specialists say the United States is currently divided between two distinct housing markets: one where inventories are brimming, like Phoenix, and the other, like Boston, where available homes are scarce, and prices continue to rise.
“This is bifurcation. The nation is split in two. It’s pointless to make generalizations about the country as a whole. All buyers should thoroughly investigate before submitting any offers,” says Mark Nash, a longtime real estate broker in the Chicago metro area.
Nash doesn’t know the would-be buyer in Arizona, who’s been surveying property since last spring. But he’s not surprised the man is so selective.
“This is a rational approach for all first-time buyers and especially for purchasers in high-inventory markets,” says Nash, author of “1001 Tips for Buying and Selling a Home.”
Housing economists agree that wannabe homebuyers are getting increasingly choosey.
“Most house hunters aren’t flat-out stopping their search. Instead, they’re being picky and looking for the perfect home,” says Rebecca Love, a Redfin real estate agent.
Love is based in Washington, D.C., where home sales have slowed due to federal cutbacks, causing buyers to be particularly selective.
“Buyers are ultra-cautious with their funds because they’re worried about interest rates, the economy and potentially losing their job. If they’re going to spend money, they want to check every box. At the same time, they want a good deal. That means searches are taking longer than usual,” she says.
Here are a few pointers for buyers:
-- Begin your quest for a first home at a friendly lender’s office.
Eric Tyson, co-author of “Home Buying for Dummies,” notes that years after the Great Recession of 2008, most mortgage lenders are still stringent in their requirements of borrowers. That means all home loan applicants continue to face significant scrutiny.
“Count on your lender looking closely at your credit history and asking lots of questions about your income and assets. This is particularly likely if you’re self-employed or work on commission,” Tyson says.
By seeing a mortgage lender early, you have time to get mortgage preapproval, which will give you a realistic sense of how much you can afford. A preapproval letter is also a strong bargaining chip.
“This makes you a lot more credible with your sellers,” he says.
-- Screen for highly motivated sellers.
Although there are now neighborhoods with lots of unsold homes, some sellers are more inclined to negotiate than others. As Nash says, one key to finding a good deal is to search for owners who are exceptionally motivated.
One way of identifying highly motivated sellers is to examine statistics. Ask your real estate agent to determine the average “days on market” (from list to sale) for properties in the area where you want to live. Then look for homes in your price range that have sat unsold for a longer-than-average period, which gives them a stigma.
Before crafting an offer, also consider another set of numbers: the average list-to-sale price differential. If you note that most properties have recently fetched 95% of their list price, you might consider a first bid at a 5% discount off what’s being asked, assuming your research shows this is warranted.
-- Never try to negotiate through insults.
Suppose you’re seriously considering a home that would comfortably house your family. But you notice a few minor shortcomings.
Nash says some purchasers attempt to strengthen their bargaining position by writing a letter that highlights minor flaws with a property or by noting the owners’ poor taste.
Should you take this approach? Absolutely not, longtime agents say.
“Nearly every human being takes pride in their home. Chide the owners and you’ll only worsen your bargaining stance,” says Dorcas Helfant, a past president of the National Association of Realtors.
This isn’t to say that you and your home inspector shouldn’t be forthright in itemizing corrections needed to bring the property up to standard, such as repairs to the roof or the replacement of a malfunctioning water heater. But do so in a manner that doesn’t offend the owners.
“At the end of the day, make sure you’re direct but without vilifying the sellers,” Helfant says.
(To contact Ellen James Martin, email her at ellenjamesmartin@gmail.com.)