A young doctor at Cleveland Clinic has just taken a staff position there. Finally, he’ll make a substantial enough salary to afford a house of his own. After years as a renter, he’s elated at the prospect. But the path forward in his favorite Cleveland neighborhood of University Circle is rougher than expected.
“For months, friends all over the country have been telling me this is a great time to get a deal on a house. They say prices are falling and countless unsold homes are sitting. But none of that is true in University Circle,” the doctor says.
Indeed, a new report from real estate giant Zillow that covers the nation’s 50 largest metros cites Cleveland along with four other cities as places where home values are continuing to rise.
Kara Ng, a senior economist for Zillow, says that within the last year, home values in Cleveland rose 4.7%. They increased 4.5% in Hartford, 3.9% in Louisville, 3.8% in Detroit and 3.7% in Buffalo.
Of course, as Ng notes, “these gains are modest compared to the rampant double-digit growth seen three or four years ago,” when pandemic-era housing demand greatly outstripped supply.
Florida and Texas, former hot spots with sellers’ markets and skyrocketing prices, are areas where values are now falling. In specific, Ng singles out Tampa, Austin, Miami, Orlando and Dallas as metros where values are gradually declining.
Despite the fact that buyers are gaining leverage in many metros, where sellers are cutting prices, affordability remains the paramount challenge.
According to Ng, home values rose over last year in 25 major markets, mostly in the Midwest and Northeast. Demand is high -- especially in affordable areas -- but building restrictions put a damper on new and higher-density projects. Sellers have few options to move up to, and existing inventory is still below pre-pandemic averages in many metros.”
Despite the statistics, the Cleveland doctor hasn’t given up his quest to buy his first house in University Circle, where available properties remain scarce. But he acknowledges the need to compromise on home features and square footage to buy in that culturally rich and convenient part of town.
“Home shopping around University Circle is teaching me that both patience and compromise are essential to get the most for my money,” he says.
Here are a few pointers for buyers facing difficult trade-offs:
-- Do a love-hate analysis of your current housing.
Michael Crowley, a longtime real estate broker in Spokane, says he’s been struck by the intensity of peoples’ feelings about the place where they live.
An assessment of these feelings is a good jumping off point for setting priorities.
“As a starting point, write down the positives and negatives of your present residence. Then make a list of features you’ve got to have, would like to have or are willing to give up,” says Crowley, a past president of the National Association of Exclusive Buyer Agents (naeba.org).
Suppose the townhouse where you’re living leaves you feeling extremely crowded. Then you may decide that owning a detached property takes precedence over owning a townhouse that offers you more square feet for the same amount of money.
“Most buyers have a strict affordability ceiling. So they need clarity on what’s vital for them versus what’s just nice to have,” Crowley says.
-- Choose features early when buying a brand-new home.
If you decide to buy in a new subdivision, you’re likely to be faced with lots of tradeoffs before your contract is even written.
“Locked inside the builder’s standard price are likely to be lump-sum allowances for anything ranging from kitchen appliances to lighting fixtures and landscaping. Go over those allowances and you’ll be charged extra,” Crowley says.
These choices should be made before the sales contract is written -- not under pressure from a hurried salesperson.
Money-constrained buyers who confront hard choices may wish to delay those items that can be readily installed later, such as upgraded landscaping.
-- Think seriously before buying a fixer-upper.
Given your budget ceiling, you may think purchasing an older home in poor condition is a smart way to shoehorn yourself into a prized neighborhood or to obtain the largest possible property with limited funds.
But Crowley cautions that fixer-uppers often require vastly more money and effort to repair than their would-be buyers believe.
“Maybe you only see problems on the surface that you figure you could easily fix. But investigate what’s going on behind the walls, where there could be hidden defects,” Crowley says.
Crowley urges that money-strapped purchasers get reliable estimates on the cost of restoring a property to its former glory before committing to a purchase. For bids on the work, your real estate agent should be able to help arrange for contractors.
Planning to tackle the home improvement work yourself? If so, you may wish to canvass friends who know you well, Crowley suggests. Ask them if they think do-it-yourself work is a realistic option for you -- both from the point of view of your skill and available time.
“Taking on a fixer could be a mammoth commitment. So it’s essential to know what you’re getting yourself into,” Crowley says.
(To contact Ellen James Martin, email her at ellenjamesmartin@gmail.com.)